Will Ayush be able to challenge the Patanjali juggernaut?

It was in 2001 that Hindustan Unilever (HUL) launched Ayush, the Ayurveda based portfolio of wellness products. The brand was later shut down as it didn’t find much traction with the audience. The brand was ostensibly targeted at the premium customers who would embrace it for its ayurvedic core values. HUL representatives claimed that the products were ‘ahead of time’.

The Rise of Patanjali

The year 2006 welcomed another kid on the CPG (Consumer Packaged Goods) platform that touted itself as the ayurvedic alternative for all the ‘unhealthy’ and ‘westernised’ products. Clubbed with the ‘nationalist’ sentiment the brand struck a chord with a mass audience, majorly due to its brand ambassador, Yoga-guru Baba Ramdev. To add, right pricing for the right audience hit the sweet spot of the Indian consumers and the cash registers stated ringing for the brand. Patanjali soon became a household name and crossed a revenue mark of 10,000 crores in the last financial year displacing major bigwigs of the FMCG (Fast Moving Consumer Goods) industry.

Baba Ramdev, who already had won millions of followers through his Yoga practice, promoted the products in an unbashed manner. For his followers it was a marriage made in heaven between their favourite Yoga-guru and Ayurvedic products. His follower base that majorly came from tier-2 and below cities stood by Patanjali and helped it rise miraculously. Media channels like Aastha and Sanskar in the played a major role in making Baba Ramdev a houshold name in 2000s. Even he himself acknowledge the fact that media was a big factor in the rise of the brand.

India is a price sensitive market when it comes to CPGs and the right pricing almost always holds the key for the success of a product. Failure to do so can wipe the brand off the shelves of stores and minds of customers in no time. Patanjali got it right here too.

Patanjali hit the jackpot with the trinity of – Brand Ambassador, Brand Resonance and Pricing. A very difficult but extremely rewarding endeavor.

Positive Word-of-Mouth

Patanjali also succeeded in acquiring new customers and retain the old ones by creating a positive perception of the quality of products, which was subconsciously influenced by its reasonable prices. After consumer acquisition, Patanjali products were able to make good of the promise made to them hence eliciting a positive post-purchase behaviour largely driven by the Halo effect and lower financial risk due to cheaper products.

On the other hand when Ayush was launched as a premium brand in 2001, the market wasn’t gungg-ho about Ayurveda based products. Ayush could not offer anything concrete to its audience to trust (HULs house of brand strategy was not very helpful). Subsequently, the audience turned a blind eye to the products. The Brand had to be shut in the aftermath of consistent poor performance.

Brand Ambassador

Among the three aspects highlighted, Brand Ambassador was the key in the phenomenal rise of the Patanjali Brand. Baba Ramdev never shied away from marketing Patanjali brand and while his followers went by every word he said about the products and Patanjali, even those who did not follow Baba Ramdev were able to trust the credibility around the brand. His unapologetic rant against the MNCs also made him the poster-boy of nationalistic sentiment that clicked with the burgeoning middle class of the country. On the other hand, Ayush has brought in film stars Akshay Kumar and Tamanna as brand ambassadors. This was a run-of-mill approach as both the actors have no genuine link with Ayurveda and are seen in many other ads that create more confusion then clarity. The ad showing the actors also chose to claim to be the real Ayurveda based brand which may be perceived as arrogant or even petty. Due to the missing connect with the core offering of the brand, the ambassadors stand no chance against the massive appeal of Baba Ramdev and his Patanjali products.

Brand Resonance

The core offering of the Patanjali brand was no-nonsense Ayurveda based products which didn’t have fancy packaging and touched up images of good looking models. The ads also didn’t look ‘rich’ and were intentionally painted ‘simple’ to demonstrate its values. This strategy personified the brand as honest, simple and trustworthy, hence making people believe in the offering. Ayurveda based products must be able to invoke emotions like  purity and trust due to many factors like – lack of knowledge in people regarding the roots of the products, formulation and application, mushrooming of a huge number of Ayurveda based product companies and finally the perceived physical and health risks involved in using the products. Ayush has maintained its premium packaging and hasn’t been able to come up with a major differentiator vis a vis a host of other products available in the market. In absence of a strong usp, it hasn’t been able to make any specific place for itself in the segment.

Pricing

In terms of pricing, while Ayush has shed the premium tag with its re-launch a quick analysis of the products show that they are still quite expensive than Patanjali. The Ayush products taken into consideration are anything between 33% to 94% expensive than Patanjali products. Clearly, the reference point for Ayurveda based products in customers’s mind is Patanjali and a quick comparison between Patanjali and Ayush products will lead to an easy choice for her, if it is based on price only. With a more than satisfied customer base of Patanjali products, Ayush doesn’t have footing on the quality attribute either while some detractors and a small customer base who map uality on price may give Ayush a shot. But this will be a small base, far from viability for HUL. Hence, the price point becomes even more important which doesn’t seem to be helping Ayush.

In a nut-shell, Ayush’s relaunch by HUL may be more of optimism and an 'easy way out' rather than a of rational ‘Product Development’ growth strategy. Whether Ayush has more punches to pull in future, only time will tell. As of now, it doesn’t seem to be too much of a worry for Patanjali.